TOP 21 FAVORITE WESTERNS -- MONTE WALSH

#2

MONTE WALSH (NGP, 1970)

 
DIRECTOR: William A. Fraker;  PRODUCERS: Hal Landers and Bobby Roberts; WRITERS: David Z. Goodman and Lucas Heller from story by Jack Schafer;  CINEMATOGRAPHY: David M. Walsh

CAST: Lee Marvin, Jeanne Moreau, Jack Palance, Mitchell Ryan, Jim Davis, G.D. Spradlin, John Hudkins, Raymond Guth, John McKee, Michael Conrad, Tom Heaton, Ted Gehring, Bo Hopkins, John McLiam, Allyn Ann McLerie, Matt Clark, Billy Green Bush, Eric Christmas, Charles Tyner, Richard Farnsworth, Guy Wilkerson, Roy Barcroft

“The good times are coming

They’ll be coming real soon

And I’m not just pitching pennies at the moon”

(NOTE: Earlier I wrote about my introduction to MONTE WALSH and if you wish, you may read about it here)

THE PLOT.

This underrated and unappreciated classic film is the best depiction of the hardship, humdrum drudgery, good humor, and camaraderie of cowboy life ever filmed.

Railroad expansion has made the long cattle drive obsolete; the open range has been fenced in; and a bitterly harsh winter has forced the local ranchers to sell out to a corporation, the Consolidated Land Company.  The land company, like corporations everywhere, does not possess a conscience.  Accountants are in charge, money has become capital, and the primary concern is the bottom line. 

All these factors have a basis in historical reality, including the harsh winter.  Blizzards in the 1880s bankrupted many ranchers and exerted a long-range transformative effect on Western cattle ranching.

Sadly, these events conspire to make the cowboy – or most of them, anyway -- obsolete. 

Nevertheless, two aging cowboys (Marvin and Palance) try to continue as though nothing has changed, but the economic forces of the era are working against them.  In the short run, they are more fortunate than some of the other cowhands.  

Cal Brennan (Davis), the former owner of the Slash Y, is now an employee of the land company.  As ranch manager, he is forced by the company’s absentee property owners to downsize the workforce.  He does so by laying-off the younger men, which allows Monte (Marvin) and Chet (Palance) a reprieve – at least for the time being.

“I’m not about to come unhinged when everything goes wrong
A fact is something to be faced
But not for very long”

Monte is an optimist, one could say an idealist.  No matter what bad things come his way, and many bad things do, he nevertheless retains his optimism.  Many idealists become cynics when events transpire against them and their ideals do not carry the day, but not Monte.  

He loses everything that he cherishes, his friends, especially Chet, the woman he loves, and is on the verge of losing his way of life, but he never gives up the battle to retain his self-respect, his optimism, or his sense of humor, even though he is reduced to telling stories to his horse in the film’s final scene.

Chet, on the other hand, is more pragmatic than his partner.  He has seen the handwriting on the wall and finally realizes that it is time to accept reality and to adjust accordingly.  

The most poignant moment in what is a very poignant film occurs when Chet finally concedes and decides to quit cowboy life and marry a town widow (McLerie) who owns a hardware store:

MONTE WALSH (Lee Marvin): “Cowboys don’t get married, unless they stop being cowboys.”

CHET ROLLINS (Jack Palance): “Nobody gets to be a cowboy forever.”

How true, but how sad.

“I ain’t doin’ nothin’ I can’t do from my horse.” – MONTE WALSH (Lee Marvin)

Shorty Austin (Ryan), a buddy to Monte and Chet, is one of the younger cowboys who loses his job.  He teams up with a couple of other men (Bush and Clark) who are in the same fix.  The trio of ex-cowhands respond to the changing times by taking to the outlaw trail with tragic consequences for Chet and Monte.

There isn’t a lot of action or violence or gunplay in MONTE WALSH.   It is a character-driven story that spends the first half of the movie establishing the characters and the changing circumstances they must confront.  The lack of action is the primary reason that some critics have been negative in their reviews.  But there is a great deal to like, including outstanding performances by the cast, good direction and writing, and stunning location photography.

Colin over at Riding the High Country perfectly summarizes the movie’s appeal when he writes, “[t]his is a remarkable film, a work of gentle and understated power, one which can break your heart and yet fill it up with renewed optimism at the same time.”   

THE STARS.

Ironically, Marvin, in THE MAN WHO SHOT LIBERTY VALANCE (Ford/Paramount, 1962), and Palance, in SHANE (Paramount, 1953), gave us two of the meanest, most unredeemable, and most memorable bad guys ever to appear on the screen.  But here they are excellent in  good-guy roles.

Roger Ebert wrote in the Chicago Sun-Times:

“The performances are extraordinary.  Marvin has very seldom been better; he leaves in the toughness of his usual screen character, but he also reveals a lot of depth….[Y]ou’re reminded once again what a good actor Palance is, and how seldom he gets the opportunity to prove it.”

However, here is another view.

Vincent Canby wrote in his review of the film in the New York Times that MONTE WALSH “is not a very good movie, but one that is often appealing in its individual parts.”   

He is also critical of Marvin’s performance:

“I suppose that Marvin seemed like an excellent choice for the title role.  He is tough, grizzled, a little crazy, but he is also turning professionally cute, given to comic mannerisms that are beginning to remind me more and more of Andy Clyde—but this may be because the film includes a rather exuberant outhouse routine.”

Andy Clyde?  Come now, Mr. Canby.  Furthermore, just how is it that Andy Clyde and “a rather exuberant outhouse routine” are related?  

Canby has better things to say about Palance, Moreau, and Ryan, but also complains that the story’s principal villains, the property owners, are 2,500 miles away, off screen, and communicate via letter and telegraph. 

Well, that’s the way it really was.

“The good times are coming

When they come I’ll be there

With both my feet planted in mid-air”

One of the great strengths of the film is how well Marvin and Palance relate to each other.  That could be because they knew each other quite well, having appeared together in two films before this one.  In 1956, Palance, in an electrifying performance, starred in the intense WWII drama, ATTACK! (UA, directed by Robert Aldrich), with Lee Marvin very good in a supporting role.  

A decade later, after his Oscar winning performance in CAT BALLOU (Columbia, 1965) had elevated him to leading man status , Marvin starred with Burt Lancaster in THE PROFESSIONALS (Columbia, 1966, directed by Richard Brooks), with Palance in a supporting role.

In the realm of what might have been, I have read that Marvin turned down a role in THE WILD BUNCH (WB, 1969) in order to star in PAINT YOUR WAGON (Paramount, 1969), the film he appeared in just prior to MONTE WALSH. I suppose it seemed to be a good idea at the time.    

Jeanne Moreau gives a touching performance as Martine Benard, a prostitute who loves Monte, but understands that marriage is probably not in their future.  

In their scenes together, it is obvious that there is some real chemistry between Moreau and Marvin.  She was later quoted as saying, “Lee Marvin is more male than anyone I have ever acted with.  He is the greatest man’s man I have ever met and that includes all the European stars I have worked with.” 

In the course of her career, Jeanne Moreau acted in more than a hundred movies and dozens of plays and she was a huge star – especially in Europe.   

In 2001, Jeff Galipeaux wrote on the Salon website that Moreau “is the heavyweight of 60s cinema, and so far, the last of the heavyweights.  In the decades since Moreau’s heyday, many fine welterweights have come up through the ranks…but no one who could have handled her run of 60s films with the intelligence, wisdom, range and unself-consciousness she conveys with preternatural ease.”

THE SUPPORTING CAST.

The stars have much able support beginning with Mitchell Ryan, in only his third feature film, and Jim Davis appearing in his 86th.

three memorable cowboys: (L-R) -- Monte Walsh, Cal Brennan, Chet Rollins

Davis, much like John Ireland, was always an effective performer in Westerns.  It is hard to figure, but neither got the big break that he deserved.  They often gave good performances in supporting roles in bigger-budget productions and were nearly always better than the low-budget movies in which they starred.

It was well nigh impossible to make a Western in the 70s without casting Matt Clark in a supporting role.  MONTE WALSH is no exception and Clark is very good as Rufus Brady, one of the cowboys who respond to hard times by becoming an outlaw.  His partner in crime, in addition to Shorty Austin (Ryan), is another very good supporting actor, Billy Green Bush.  I really like his name in this movie: Powder Kent.  I even like the name Billy Green Bush.

"There's gonna be a place for us
A place where we belong
To stand outside just looking in
Has got to be all wrong"

THE DIRECTOR.

MONTE WALSH was William Fraker’s first film as director.  It was an impressive debut and showed great promise for the future.  However, he directed only two other films. 

He was more interested in cinematography, the job that had made him famous.  During his illustrious career, he received five Academy Award nominations for Best Cinematography.  

His expertise in that area is ever apparent in the outstanding utilization of Arizona locations in MONTE WALSH.  He and cinematographer David Walsh teamed to give us a beautiful film.

William Fraker, Director

What were the two other films that he directed?   Well, that probably should be left unsaid since they certainly didn’t come up to the standards of his debut, that’s for sure.  

Roger Greenspun wrote in his review of Fraker’s second directorial effort, A REFLECTION OF FEAR (Columbia, 1973), that “there is such a density of atmospheric haze that half the film looks as if it had been photographed through  a jellyfish.” (Ouch!).  It must have quickly faded into oblivion because I don’t know of anyone who has ever seen it.

His third film could not be criticized for its photography,  but unfortunately,  he was done in by his star, the one-and-only Klinton Spilsbury.  Beautifully photographed in New Mexico and Monument Valley, THE LEGEND OF THE LONE RANGER (Universal, 1981) could not overcome a star whose acting was so atrocious that his dialogue had to be dubbed by James Keach.

No wonder Fraker returned full-time to cinematography after that one.  He was fortunate to have a fallback position.  Klinton Spilsbury didn’t.  It was his first and last appearance on the screen – big or small.

THE WRITERS.

The film’s original source material is an episodic novel by the same title written by Jack Schaefer, and published in 1963. Schaefer, of course, is known primarily as the author of Shane, a much more famous book.  However, he was quoted as saying that he thought Monte Walsh was a better novel.  I have to agree with him. It is one of my favorite novels – Western or otherwise.

The screenplay was placed in the capable hands of David Goodman and Lucas Heller.  They took great liberties in adapting Schaefer’s novel to the extent that it is possible to enjoy both without one ruining the other. Despite the differences that exist between the novel and the screenplay, I highly recommend both.

THE MUSIC.

The film has been criticized by some (Brian Garfield for one, but not me) for its theme song, “The Good Times are Coming,” which is sung by Cass Elliott over the opening credits, and at other times during the film.  

Personally, I love the song (music by John Barry and lyrics by Hal David) and I think that it fits the mood of the movie like a comfortable old shoe.  In fact, it takes days to get it out of my head after hearing it.

Also adding a nice touch are the Charlie Russell sketches that serve as a backdrop for the opening credits.  Cass Elliott and Charlie Russell – now that’s a winning combination.

 

"The good times are coming"

******

REVIEWS:

“Generally underrated,  MONTE WALSH is a fine film in its elegiac depiction of real cowboy life; it’s better and more honest, for example, than the similar WILL PENNY [Paramount, 1968].” – Brian Garfield in Western Films: A Complete Guide

“…Marvin and Palance (a wonderful grin playing across his face for most of the film) give an example of the inarticulate but good-humored friendship that alleviates the drudgery of a cowboy’s life.” – Phil Hardy in The Western

And now for an opposing viewpoint:

“…MONTE WALSH is handled with such meditative pacing and melodramatic deliberation that it continually threatens to put the viewer to sleep.  Interest is maintained by Lee Marvin and Jack Palance…who manage to come across as aging ranch hands….First-time director Fraker managed to conjure up a grimy, naturalistic view of the dog-eared West that is effective.” – Steven H. Scheuer

Because of superior cinematography, MONTE WALSH is a more enjoyable film if it is viewed on a large movie screen, which I had the privilege of doing.  However, it is still a treat on a small screen.  

You can watch it on YouTube.